Results 1 to 20 of 43
-
25-06-2022, 08:50 PM #1
Choosing a New Kohaku..... Which one?
First fish into my dedicated Koi-only pond was a cheap 8cm long £16 Sakai Kohaku. Not a terrible Koi by any means, but didn't really grow except for a tiny growth spurt in 2020, and now at 5 years old she's reached the grand size of 44cm and starting to lose beni.
Always wanted a nice Kohaku but kept waiting until a time came when I felt confident enough to try and choose a nice one at an amount I'm willing to spend on a Koi.... i.e not a lot seeing as the most expensive Koi in my pond was £350.
The problem with Kohaku is I keep changing my mind about favourite patterns..... Used to be the big 2 steps with a white stripe around the middle, then I liked 3 steps, then started to find 3 steps boring so got into 4 steps.... and after a while decided I just want something with a funky pattern but still a preference for 4 steps.
Yeah... pattern first for me, trying to get the whole package is obviously the aim, just limited by budget.
So I've been looking seriously since about February and lost out on one or 2, but here are the final contenders, all bowled and viewed in person, but before posting which one I went for I'd love to know what your choice would be and why.....and don't be afraid to say they are all rubbish, just give a reason why
Kohaku 1: Matsue female Tosai, 32cm
Kohaku no.2: Matsue unsexed Tosai (but looks male) 31cm
Kohaku no.3: Takigawa unsexed Tosai, 27cm:
Last edited by RS2OOO; 25-06-2022 at 09:13 PM.
-
samp09 Thanked / Liked this Post
-
25-06-2022, 10:35 PM #2
Number 1 for me . Really like that
3 looks to have some shoulders on it but the pecs like pointed and deeper colour so possibly a male ? ?
Sent from my SM-G973F using TapatalkFreddyboy the legend
"we are water keepers first"
Johnathan
-
RS2OOO Thanked / Liked this Post
-
26-06-2022, 07:21 AM #3
Number 1 for me too as like you, I like a funky pattern on a Kohaku! You could always pay Adam Byer a visit when he releases his kohaku if you wanted another one, great quality and very well priced too!
-
26-06-2022, 08:18 AM #4
Shame about the beni on the tail end of number 1 if that was not there then great fish BUT number 2 for me big pecs and nice pattern and shoulders and the beni stop just before the tail making the fish look bigger when larger will be a big fish
-
RS2OOO Thanked / Liked this Post
-
26-06-2022, 09:22 AM #5
Number 2 for me aswell big pecs and nice pattern great whites. number 1 pattern all over the place and don’t like the eyes makes them look like they pop out
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
RS2OOO Thanked / Liked this Post
-
26-06-2022, 10:34 AM #6
Out of those three, I would opt for number 2
7500 litres
Filtreau combi with uv.
Some koi
-
RS2OOO Thanked / Liked this Post
-
26-06-2022, 10:47 AM #7
another one for number 2,
i just have a thing about not liking the googley eyes on koi number 1
though that could change when much bigger...
a good point by colin about the pattern when bigger on number 2, would look much more imposing.
-
RS2OOO Thanked / Liked this Post
-
26-06-2022, 12:59 PM #8
No 2 for me a clear four step kohaku but as mentioned already if possible a visit to Adam Byers could well change your mind again.
If only i lived nearer.
keith
-
26-06-2022, 01:55 PM #9
-
RS2OOO Thanked / Liked this Post
-
26-06-2022, 03:24 PM #10
No 1 stands out for me and good sized female tosai.
Fibreglassed/5000 gals/4.5 m Tunnel/Spindrifter/Twin drums/Bio chambers/Beads/Showers/Remora ASHP
-
RS2OOO Thanked / Liked this Post
-
26-06-2022, 04:03 PM #11
Number 2 for me.
34,000L, 2xSpindrifters, Aqua Sieve2, Nexus300, 24in K1/bead, Momotaro Bakki, 17kwThermotec Inverter
-
RS2OOO Thanked / Liked this Post
-
26-06-2022, 06:31 PM #12
Wow, thanks for so many opinions. Glad so many of you replied.
Going to shock you all now..... I went with no.3 !!!!!
Nobody on a couple of Whatsapp Koi groups I post to picked number 3 either.
No.1 was my first choice, even put a deposit on it before viewing.
Went to view no.2 and no.3 and out of 100 Kohaku in the vat number 2 stood out loads, the Shiroji was incredible, another level compared to anything else in the vat, and the beni was so deep, easily in the top 3.
Bowled it and liked it, but the body looked weak, quite shallow especially towards the back, almost certainly male with a typical slender male body. The Sashi extended forward by 2 or 3 scales (not clear in the Dealer photo - but see video I took below), so not sure how it would turn out, definitely a gamble, but the slender body and shallow backbone kept putting me off, so number 3 was added to the bowl to compare. Number 3 instantly stood out as having much better proportions, has a softer beni (a female trait at Tosai), the vent looked more female than male, the sashi and kiwa look much more refined (a male trait maybe), the shiroji not quite as white as no.2 but still in the top 10 within the vat. Pattern is nice but definitely less interesting, maybe even boring, but its a big koi pattern that will grow with the fish, whereas I felt as a big fish no.2 would have too much white space between the beni steps. The body on number 3 was way better, a lot more balanced, something that is hard to see in the photos.
So now it was between no.1 and no.3.
Went to view no.1 and it would be fair to say it does not look like the photo. Interestingly this Koi was selected by Mike Snaden, which does kind of sway you a little bit but at the end of the day he's choosing koi to match a set budget.
I Appreciate no.1 had just come out of QT and was a bit skinny as expected, but to my untrained eyes, and they really are untrained as far as Tosai are concerned, the beni looked really weak, a very light orange and a few scales that already looked to have fading beni plus a few areas where I felt the colour might break up. Shiroji was hard to judge as it was off-white due to the environment it was being kept in. Body was really good, I just thought the beni had too many risks for a £495 koi, plus there was a dodgy patch of "flowery" secondary beni lower down covering about 5 or 6 scales - a compromise I'd have lived with if the rest of the Koi was excellent.
So there you have it - from the pictures no.1 was my favourite, no.2 second favourite, and no.3 last, yet having viewed in person I came home with number 3 (the cheapest of the 3) and whilst the pattern isn't super interesting, I think it will be a solid reliable Koi, and from a great breeder.
Here's a video of 2 and 3 in the bowl together (this was 1 week after arrival in the UK, so still in QT and not being fed):
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/6Ivt0bg5aoY
And here's a photo of no.3 on collection day, after QT was completed and the Dealer was conditioning them for sale:
And for interest here's my own photo of no.2 where you can better see the sashi. This will tighten up but I reckon by the end of it there will be even less beni than there is now and the Koi will have too much white-ground when it is bigger. My guess is that the body will always be slender, but could end up being very wrong on that count. The Shiroji though, it is incredible for the price no doubt about that.
For anyone interested the Kohaku 1 is still for sale at Gatwick Koi and Kohaku 2 available from Koi Waterlife.
For sure I wish number 1 was as I hoped it would be when placing a deposit, and I wish number 2 had a better body shape because the colouration was outstanding and the pattern really nice, but for me number 3 was the best overall Koi and really looks good in the pond.
Wish I could have had all 3 just to see them develop, but will post an update next year so you can see how number 3 turns out.Last edited by RS2OOO; 26-06-2022 at 06:59 PM.
-
26-06-2022, 07:22 PM #13
Your fish at the end of the day Rs and a very nice choice.
What I liked about no 2 was the broad head even though it had a slender body and probably Male.
Did you say they were tosai?John
-
RS2OOO Thanked / Liked this Post
-
26-06-2022, 07:26 PM #14
All 3 were Tosai John, and not bad sizes for Tosai either.
Considering the prices of everything these days I think all 3 were worth the asking prices.
Will never 100% know if I picked the right one - need people on here to grab the other 2 , but I'm happy with the end result, its a nice quality Koi for sure.
-
26-06-2022, 07:39 PM #15Freddyboy the legend
"we are water keepers first"
Johnathan
-
26-06-2022, 08:00 PM #16
As above mate, look on Gatwick koi's website, Matsue Tosai Kohaku, £495.
Compare it to everything else on his website at that price range and it does look a great deal for the money, especially being female.
Only thing is Johnathan, he doesn't post koi as far as I know, which means you'd have to venture South and endure all the rude gobby southerners
Sent from my Pixel 4a using TapatalkLast edited by RS2OOO; 26-06-2022 at 08:02 PM.
-
26-06-2022, 08:09 PM #17
-
26-06-2022, 08:56 PM #18Freddyboy the legend
"we are water keepers first"
Johnathan
-
26-06-2022, 08:56 PM #19Freddyboy the legend
"we are water keepers first"
Johnathan
-
26-06-2022, 09:51 PM #20
-
RS2OOO Thanked / Liked this Post
The Daily pond temp thread
Pond still covered, currently 11.6C Been really mild this year as far as pond temps go. ...